RITZLFILM
Industry

Out, Damned Grey

In September Teltec Wien / AV-Professional invited people to colour grading seminars, as part of Teltec’s extensive seminar programme and as a small foretaste of the seminars on offer at Photo+Adventure + Film+Video in Vienna. Wolfgang Ritzberger took a seat in the classroom and listened.

Colour correction is an art that needs solid craft as its foundation, the speaker, Klaus W. Rößel, stated right at the start. “One could argue for ever about more or less red, but to get that far at all one has to master the craft.” The seminars were scheduled over three days: day one Adobe Premiere, day two DaVinci Resolve and day three Final Cut Pro X. To cut it short, the first day was overbooked, on the second we were a cosy little gathering, and in FCX nobody much was interested. At least not on these dates in Vienna. What do we learn from that? Rößel: “More that Apple finds no resonance here. The aura seems to have gone, and above all the fans of the earlier versions did not follow the new philosophy behind FCX.” That Premiere drew the biggest crowd did not much surprise Klaus Rößel, for Premiere has established itself fairly well, in Europe above all, while DaVinci, though almost freeware, remains a niche product.

In principle all three programs work the same way, says the expert. In each case the colour correction is closely tied to the editing program, and both also work almost seamlessly with other programs from the same makers, such as After Effects from Adobe or Fusion from BM. The differences lie more in the architecture of the programs and in what they were meant for. “Premiere and FCX, like Avid, are really broadcast programs, whereas the DaVinci software was designed for digital film,” Rößel explains. One of the essential differences, he says, is also to be found in the management of the original material. DaVinci mercilessly transfers the original material into the DaVinci colour space (32-bit float). The other programs render dissolves, for example, while editing, and then only that short stretch (complete rendering happens only on output or with a separate program). DaVinci creates a complete copy of the source material in the new colour space.

Premiere and FCX, like Avid, are really broadcast programs, whereas the DaVinci software was designed for digital film

That, incidentally, is one reason why DaVinci Resolve is a resource hog. The maker itself gives 32 GB of memory as the minimum requirement but recommends considerably more, above all for using Fusion. The graphics card, too, needs a fairly broad chest if Blackmagic’s programs are to run smoothly.

At the start Rößel sketches the set-up for professional colour grading and, to say it straight away, an edit suite alone is not enough. It begins with the colours of the furniture and the walls, continues with the ambient light and ends with the hardware in use. Rößel shows a photograph and wants to know what is wrong with it. Much head-scratching, despite a large helping of theory on the difference between colour models and colour spaces, served with a decent portion of physics (“Light has a dual nature: wave and particle!” “We are still animals that came out of the forest, which is why we perceive green best!” “Light is always analogue, we merely translate light into digital signals!”). The edit suite in the photograph looks perfectly neat: a large monitor on the wall, three monitors close by, evidently large speakers as audio monitors and so on. What is supposed to be wrong with that? Answer: the red table, for red is not only a critical colour, as we all know, but in this case an extreme hindrance as well. Because the eye is constantly roaming its surroundings and constantly performing what amounts to an automatic white balance. “There is nothing we can do about it, we are programmed that way,” Rößel explains, “which here means that the eye is constantly balancing against the red of the table, which then leads to, shall we say, interesting results in the grade.” Dimmed light, ten per cent of the monitor’s light, and that too should be at 50 per cent at most (Rößel: “The reference is 100 cd/m², a monitor generally has more than 200, the new Apple displays up to 500 cd/m².”), grey as the background to the monitors, a dark table (Rößel: “The table can be white too, only then the ambient light has to be lowered still further.”) and above all no disturbing source of light from outside, through a window for instance.

The reference monitor

What the trainer, who is in demand internationally, also demonstrated impressively: a computer screen is not a reference monitor. Here too solid knowledge is called for. From gamma to colour space, the reference monitor should be adjustable. Rößel: “You can perfectly well use a computer screen for it, only it should be adjustable and take the video signal from a breakout box. By now a number of manufacturers offer monitors equipped specifically for video with these options.” And while we are at it, if you want to see the same thing everywhere, 50 hertz at 25 frames per second and 72 hertz (three times) at 24 frames per second would be in order on all screens. For feature films other rules apply anyway, for, says Rößel: “Colour correction should as far as possible be done in the environment in which the film is seen. Investing in a 2K digital cinema projector for grading cinema films is therefore hardly a mistake.” The professionals, he goes on, also do separate grades for the cinema, for the VOD platforms (there are discernible differences even between Netflix and Amazon), for conventional television and for DVD and Blu-ray.

Correction and grading

Right, and how does one do a grade? A good one, a professional one, one that deserves the title “colour artist”. For Rößel the technical check comes first. “With contrast, colour values and so on, taste plays only a small part. Here I can only set the picture up by the scopes.” He has good reasons, technical and artistic, for his personal departures from some theories. He does not push contrast to the limit in either direction. Look at feature films, says Rößel: they are very seldom graded with strong contrast. Why? Because with strong contrasts we can no longer distinguish nuances in the highlights and in the shadows. A classic vectorscope as a measuring instrument helps with this technical colour correction. Brightness and contrast, colour errors, colour balance, skin tones and the matching of differently exposed scenes. Here too the rule is that the better the source material was exposed, the better the result. “This part is not a matter of taste but, strictly speaking, physics.” Which is why, and precisely why, it is a profession and not a hobby.

Once the picture has been technically corrected, the level of personal design comes in, of dramatic effect by means of colour. That is when the sky turns poison green and the skin quite yellow, and with a few settings and masks I turn the light set by the DoP completely around. Here colour moods are used deliberately to heighten the emotional effect. The toolkit is wide. All three programs offer masks of various shapes and effects, with which I can also work on parts of the picture only. Rößel distinguishes the two parts as well: the technical one is for him colour correction, the artistic one colour grading.

Here too the rule is, first, “shit in, shit out”: completely off stays completely off. What can be corrected are errors, which do after all occur, and the colours. If it does nothing but clip or swim in noise and not even the faintest trace of structure can be made out, colour grading will not help either. And second, practice makes perfect, and that is what then makes the difference. A technical grade should be part of everyday routine, just as in the early days of professional video we used to twiddle away at the TBC (timebase corrector), ideally likewise equipped with a vectorscope as a measuring instrument. Artistic grading is a profession in its own right, almost a vocation, and it is not for nothing that the true professionals call themselves colour artists.

Insights